The DSM-5 major depressive disorder criteria look deceptively simple — nine symptoms, a threshold of five, a two-week window — and yet examiners keep writing vignettes specifically to catch candidates who memorise the list without understanding the rules around it. The diagnosis lives in the fine print: duration, distress or impairment, and a set of exclusions that turn a "textbook" presentation into a trap.
This article walks through all nine criteria, the 5+ symptoms over 2 weeks rule, how each criterion is practically tested in an exam vignette, the specifiers worth knowing, and the exclusions — substances, medical causes, grief, and above all bipolar disorder — that decide whether your answer is right. If you are sitting USMLE, MRCPsych or RANZCP psychiatry papers, this is core currency.
The 9 DSM-5 major depressive disorder criteria
DSM-5 (and DSM-5-TR, which retained these unchanged) requires five or more of nine symptoms, present during the same ≥2-week period, representing a change from previous functioning — and at least one of the symptoms must be either (1) depressed mood or (2) loss of interest or pleasure (anhedonia). Symptoms must cause clinically significant distress or impairment, and must not be attributable to a substance or another medical condition.
The two gatekeeper symptoms matter: you cannot diagnose MDD from fatigue, poor appetite, insomnia and guilt alone, no matter how many weeks they have lasted. Someone with seven somatic symptoms but preserved mood and interest does not meet the threshold.
How examiners test each criterion
Every criterion is a candidate for a one-line vignette twist. The table below maps each symptom to the way it is typically probed and the differential it is designed to provoke.
| # | DSM-5 criterion | How examiners test it |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Depressed mood most of the day, nearly every day (subjective or observed) | Gatekeeper symptom — given as "tearful", "flat affect in interview", or "says she doesn't feel like herself" |
| 2 | Markedly diminished interest or pleasure in all/almost all activities (anhedonia) | Second gatekeeper — hobbies abandoned, "nothing feels enjoyable anymore"; also the pivot for ruling in bipolarity when paired with increased energy |
| 3 | Weight/appetite change — gain or loss, ≥5% in a month | Quantified numbers ("lost 6 kg in three weeks") or the opposite: hyperphagia with hypersomnia pointing to atypical features |
| 4 | Insomnia or hypersomnia nearly every day | Early-morning awakening (classic melancholic) vs sleeping all day; distinguish from the psychomotor retardation cluster |
| 5 | Psychomotor agitation or retardation — observable by others | "Couldn't sit still in the chair" or "moves and speaks slowly"; must be observable, not the patient's subjective restlessness |
| 6 | Fatigue or loss of energy nearly every day | The most non-specific symptom — vignettes pair it with thyroid disease, anaemia, or obstructive sleep apnoea to trigger the exclusion rules |
| 7 | Worthlessness or excessive/inappropriate guilt (delusional guilt possible) | "I'm a burden to everyone" — differentiated from psychotic guilt and from survivor guilt in bereavement |
| 8 | Diminished ability to think/concentrate or indecisiveness | Reported as "can't follow the news", "re-reads the same paragraph", or a workplace error with real consequences |
| 9 | Recurrent thoughts of death, suicidal ideation, plan or attempt | Asked directly in every depression station and vignette; presence upgrades urgency and management, and is scored in case discussions |
Practical counting rule used in exam answers: tally the symptoms, check duration, check gatekeeper presence, check impairment, then run the exclusions in order. Candidates who start with the differential and work backwards tend to over-call depression — drill the counting order in Preppsy's concept library.
Specifiers you should be able to name
Specifiers do not change the diagnosis; they change the description and the management. The high-yield set:
- With anxious distress — tension, worry, restlessness; predicts higher suicide risk and poorer response.
- With melancholic features — near-complete anhedonia, diurnal mood variation (worse in the morning), psychomotor change, early awakening, excessive guilt.
- With atypical features — preserved mood reactivity plus hyperphagia, hypersomnia, leaden paralysis, longstanding interpersonal rejection sensitivity.
- With psychotic features — mood-congruent or mood-inconclusive delusions/hallucinations; historically "severe with psychosis".
- With peripartum onset — during pregnancy or within 4 weeks postpartum (this window matters in vignettes that say "two weeks after delivery").
- With seasonal pattern — regular temporal relationship to a season, full remissions in between.
- Severity — mild (fewer symptoms beyond the minimum, manageable impairment) through severe (essentially all symptoms, marked impairment).
ICD-11 uses a related but not identical depressive episode construct, so read the stem: a USMLE-style question wants DSM-5 rules; an international guideline question may want ICD-11 framing.
Exclusions: when depression is not depression
Substances and medical causes. If the episode developed during or soon after substance use (alcohol, stimulants, corticosteroids) or a medical condition (hypothyroidism, B12 deficiency, Parkinson's, Cushing's), the correct diagnosis is the substance- or medical-induced depressive disorder, not MDD. The vignette habit to watch: labs that come back abnormal at the end.
Bipolar screening. Before calling MDD, ask about prior hypomanic or manic episodes — decreased need for sleep (not insomnia), goal-directed activity lasting days, grandiosity, pressured speech. One lifetime manic episode moves the diagnosis to bipolar I; a hypomanic history without impairment rules MDD out entirely. Family history of bipolar disorder, early onset, psychomotor retardation with hypersomnia/hyperphagia, and psychotic features all raise suspicion.
Grief. DSM-5 removed the "two months" rule: bereavement-related depression is diagnosed as MDD if the full criteria are met. What matters is the symptom pattern — guilt about one's own behaviour (not the loss itself), thoughts of worthlessness, suicidal ideation focused on self-punishment. Prolonged grief disorder is a separate DSM-5-TR diagnosis with its own ≥12-month criteria. Exam questions love the "she died three weeks ago" red herring; duration after loss does not exclude MDD.
Exam trap: forgetting the bipolar exclusion
A vignette with eight depressive symptoms, a two-week duration and a past episode of "staying up all night for three days to redecorate the house" is bipolar II depression — treating it as MDD with an SSRI answer is the trap. Screen for mania/hypomania before accepting the diagnosis, every time: ask about decreased need for sleep, elevated mood, increased energy and goal-directed activity. The single highest-yield habit for depression questions is a two-question bipolar screen before you commit.
Major depressive disorder vs persistent depressive disorder
The main longitudinal differential is persistent depressive disorder (dysthymia — DSM-5 merged dysthymic disorder and chronic MDD into this single construct): depressed mood or insufficient criteria for MDD on more days than not for at least 2 years (1 year in children/adolescents), with no symptom-free remissions longer than two months. The distinctions candidates must make:
- Duration: MDD is defined by a discrete ≥2-week episode; PDD by a chronic ≥2-year pattern.
- Symptom count: PDD requires only two symptoms (plus depressed mood) by default; MDD needs five of nine.
- Course: If during the 2-year period the full MDD criteria are met for 2+ months continuously, it is a "pure dysthymia" pattern only when MDD has never been present for longer — otherwise diagnose "persistent depressive disorder with intermittent episodes of MDD".
- Severity and impairment: MDD episodes typically bring sharper functional decline; PDD grinds down quality of life more slowly — but both matter, and comorbidity is common.
NICE guidance on depression (CG90, still current practice as of 2026 — check the NICE depression guideline for updates) sits alongside these diagnostic rules with its own stepwise severity bands; know both layers, because guidelines tell you what to do and DSM-5 tells you what it is.
Frequently asked questions
How many DSM 5 major depressive disorder criteria must be present for diagnosis?
Five of the nine symptoms, during the same two-week period, with at least one being depressed mood or anhedonia, plus clinically significant distress or impairment. Changes from baseline count — someone whose usual mood is already low still needs a perceptible change. Fewer than five symptoms, even over months, does not meet MDD (though it may meet the threshold for other specified depressive disorder or persistent depressive disorder).
What is the difference between major depressive disorder and persistent depressive disorder?
Major depressive disorder is a discrete episode of ≥2 weeks with five or more of nine symptoms. Persistent depressive disorder is a chronic pattern of depressed mood or low symptom count on most days for at least two years (one year under 18), without remissions longer than two months. If full MDD criteria were met for two continuous months within that period, the DSM code reflects a mixed pattern; management-wise, chronic depressions often need a different therapeutic approach than acute episodes.
Does grief exclude a diagnosis of major depression in DSM-5-TR?
No. DSM-5 removed the bereavement exclusion: if a person who has lost someone meets the full symptom criteria for two weeks with distress or impairment, the diagnosis is MDD, regardless of how recent the death. What suggests grief rather than depression is preserved self-esteem, a symptom pattern centred on the loss, and absence of pervasive worthlessness or self-blame. Prolonged grief disorder is a separate diagnosis with its own timeframe.
Can you diagnose major depressive disorder with only four symptoms?
Not under DSM-5 — the threshold is five. Four symptoms that cause impairment may be coded as other specified depressive disorder (a clinician can note the reason, e.g. "short-duration depressive episode") or may meet persistent depressive disorder if chronic. In exam questions, never round up: count the symptoms explicitly, confirm the gatekeeper symptom, and check duration before choosing MDD.
Key takeaways
- Five of nine symptoms, ≥2 weeks, at least one gatekeeper (depressed mood or anhedonia), plus distress or impairment.
- Count symptoms first, exclude second, and treat symptom number 9 (suicidality) as an immediate management trigger.
- Specifiers (melancholic, atypical, psychotic, peripartum, anxious distress) describe the episode — they don't change the diagnosis.
- Screen for mania/hypomania before accepting any depression diagnosis; one lifetime manic episode excludes unipolar MDD.
- Grief does not exclude MDD; substances, medications and medical causes do.
- Persistent depressive disorder = chronic ≥2-year pattern; MDD = discrete ≥2-week episode — know the code rules for both.
Drill these rules until counting becomes automatic, then test yourself with fresh vignettes over on Preppsy's MRCPsych hub.
Cover image: “Sad-Mental-Illness.jpg” by Fotorech (CC0) via wikimedia commons.
